CMMC Guide · Comparisons

CMMC vs NIST 800-171, FedRAMP, ISO 27001, SOC 2 and ITAR

CMMC is how the Department of War verifies that contractors protect FCI and CUI. Other frameworks overlap with it, but none replaces it. NIST SP 800-171 is the set of requirements CMMC Level 2 checks. FedRAMP authorizes cloud services. ISO 27001 and SOC 2 are commercial certifications and reports. ITAR and EAR control exports. Work done for them counts as a head start, not as a CMMC status.

How does CMMC compare at a glance?

FrameworkWhat it isWho needs itGives CMMC status?
NIST SP 800-171Security requirements for CUI in non-federal systemsContractors with DFARS 252.204-7012No, but it is what Level 2 assesses
FedRAMPFederal authorization program for cloud servicesCloud providers selling to the governmentNo; it applies to the cloud provider
ISO/IEC 27001International standard for an information security management systemVoluntary, often asked for by customersNo
SOC 2An auditor’s report on a service organization’s controlsVoluntary, common for service providersNo
ITAR and EARU.S. export control regulationsAnyone handling export-controlled items or dataNo; a separate legal duty

Process maturity is a different topic again: CMMC and CMMI compared.

What is the difference between CMMC and NIST SP 800-171?

NIST SP 800-171 says what to do to protect CUI. CMMC checks whether you did it. The 110 requirements of CMMC Level 2 are the requirements of NIST SP 800-171, and DFARS 252.204-7012 already requires them in contracts that involve covered defense information. CMMC adds a defined assessment, a scoring method, a status with an expiry date and a yearly affirmation by a senior official.

One detail matters: CMMC and DFARS 252.204-7012 use Revision 2 of NIST SP 800-171. NIST has since published Revision 3, which restructures the requirements, but DoW contracts do not require it yet.

What the requirements cover: CMMC requirements by domain

What is the difference between CMMC and FedRAMP?

FedRAMP authorizes cloud services for government use, based on NIST SP 800-53 security baselines. CMMC assesses defense contractors. They meet when a contractor stores CUI in the cloud: DFARS 252.204-7012 then requires the cloud service to meet the FedRAMP Moderate baseline or an equivalent.

  • A FedRAMP-authorized service does not give you a CMMC status. Your own systems, users and settings are still assessed.
  • The provider’s customer responsibility matrix shows which requirements it covers and which remain yours. Record it in your system security plan.

Does ISO 27001 or SOC 2 count toward CMMC?

Not formally, but the work behind them helps. They differ from CMMC in three ways:

Approach
ISO 27001 lets you choose controls based on your own risk assessment. SOC 2 reports on controls you describe against the AICPA Trust Services Criteria. CMMC requires a fixed set of requirements, all of which must be met.
Scope
You set the scope of an ISO certificate or SOC 2 report. A CMMC scope must include every system, person and provider that handles or protects CUI.
Who decides
Commercial certification bodies issue ISO certificates, and CPA firms issue SOC 2 reports. Only a CMMC self-assessment, an authorized C3PAO or DCMA DIBCAC produces a CMMC status.

Policies, risk assessments, access reviews, incident plans and training records from these programs can often be reused as CMMC evidence once they are mapped to the specific requirements and objectives.

How does CMMC relate to ITAR and EAR?

They answer different questions. The International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR, State Department) and the Export Administration Regulations (EAR, Commerce Department) decide who may receive controlled items and technical data, including foreign persons inside your own company. CMMC decides how well your systems protect information.

The two often meet in the same file: export-controlled technical data is a common category of CUI. Meeting CMMC does not make you export compliant, and an export compliance program does not give you a CMMC status. Companies handling such data need both, and their access controls should enforce both.

Which information is CUI: FCI vs CUI explained

Questions about CMMC and other frameworks

Does ISO 27001 certification satisfy CMMC?

No. ISO 27001 is a valuable foundation, but CMMC requires its own assessment against a fixed set of requirements. Much of your ISO documentation and evidence can be reused after mapping it to those requirements.

Do we need NIST SP 800-171 Revision 3 for CMMC?

No. CMMC Level 2 and DFARS 252.204-7012 are based on Revision 2. Revision 3 is published but not yet required in DoW contracts.

Does our company need FedRAMP authorization?

Not unless you sell cloud services to the government. If you store CUI with a cloud provider, that provider must meet the FedRAMP Moderate baseline or an equivalent.

Already certified for something else?

Talk to a CMMCMARK specialist about how far your current program gets you toward CMMC and what remains.

Prefer the phone? Call +1 (202) 867-8444.

Sources